Jesus, the Enneagram, and Me

In my last post, I asked, “Are you fasting or feasting for Lent? At the time, I was still pondering what my Lenten practice might be this year. I considered giving up listening to the radio or podcasts when I’m driving. I’ve done that for Lent a few times in the past, but it would have less impact now that I’m working from home and not commuting every day. I considered adding something, but what?

Then it occurred to me that perhaps I was thinking too narrowly about fasting or feasting. Why would I need to choose between one or the other? Or to complicate matters by giving up something and adding something else? What practice during these weeks of Lent might serve as a reminder of Jesus’ sacrifice and deepen me spiritually?

Enter the Enneagram

That’s when I decided to explore the Enneagram, sometimes described as a personality test or a tool for personal growth, dismissed by some as “new age,” yet embraced by others as compatible with biblical teaching, and used even in some seminaries as part of training pastors. I know some who have taken the Enneagram and speak positively about how it helped them reflect on who God created them to be, and so deepened their relationship with God. Others say that the Enneagram is pseudoscience focused on self-realization instead of Christ.

I’ve never tried the Enneagram myself. I generally stay away from personality tests because I don’t like being pigeon-holed or labelled. (And yes, there’s probably a personality pigeon-hole for that attitude too!) Plus, I’ve heard too many people excuse their behaviour by appealing to some personality test that told them they’re an introvert or an extrovert, as if they can only and always behave one way.

Yet once I finally took the Myers-Briggs Personality Indicator—arranged by my denomination for all church staff teams—I did find it somewhat helpful, especially since we also had a psychologist explain and interpret the results with more nuance. Perhaps the Enneagram might also be helpful to me if I would give it a chance. As a Lenten practice, I could think of it as giving up my stubborn avoidance to take up a posture of curiosity.

Jesus and the Enneagram?

In that spirit, and as I explore the Enneagram over the next weeks, I’ll reflect on what it means to be human made in God’s image. I’ll reflect on Jesus, who set aside divine power to become human, then gave up his human life to suffer, die, and rise again for the sake of the world. I’ll think of my own spiritual journey with God through this Lenten season and beyond.

Have you had personal or church experience with the Enneagram? If you have any cautions or wisdom to share, please help me and others by leaving a comment.


Interested in more from When You Work for the Church? Subscribe and receive a free copy of Sabbath Rest for the People of God:

Share this post:

6 responses to “Jesus, the Enneagram, and Me”

  1. schroedereh Avatar
    schroedereh

    The enneagram has helped me a lot. A number of years ago I participated in a workshop to learn about it. When I tried to identify which personality type I was, there were two types that both seemed to be me. After some pondering I was able to choose one of them (not the one I preferred)! I had a strong wing on one of them but the other one was me. I hesitated to embrace the enneagram because I didn’t want to acknowledge a certain characteristic I didn’t like. I’ve been working on that one ever since and it has really been helpful to recognize and work on that part of my personality. Two of my sisters and I send each other our enneagram emails every day. It helps us to understand each other.

    1. April Yamasaki Avatar

      Thank you for sharing, Elfrieda. Your experience makes me even more curious! Did you choose your personality type instead of taking the test? And what enneagram emails are you exchanging with your sisters? It sounds like you have your own enneagram community instead of pursuing it on you own.

      1. schroedereh Avatar
        schroedereh

        You can ask to have an enneathought for the day sent to you: mailto:enneathought@enneagraminstitute.com

        I did take the test as well which clarified the outcome for me.

        1. April Yamasaki Avatar

          Thanks for letting me know, Elfrieda. These days, my email inbox is chronically over full, but I appreciate knowing about the enneathought for future reference. Rather than reviewing all of the types first, I’ve started with some reading about the enneagram, will take the test, and then go on from there.

  2. Angelina Van Dyke Avatar

    Thank you for this interesting Lenten reflection – the Enneagram is like a symbolic personality map. I also did the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator when I graduated from teacher’s college, but now psychological research favours the Big Five. A more Biblically grounded approach rooted in cognitive architecture is Mental Symmetry, aligning with Romans 12:2 – “renewing of your mind” and 2 Corinthians 10:5 – “take every thought captive”. Whereas the Enneagram resonates strongly with identity-based emotional structures, Mental Symmetry builds structures of truth that stabilize understanding, connecting emotion, evidence, experience, and morality.

    1. April Yamasaki Avatar

      Thanks for offering this overview, Angelina. I know a little about Mental Symmetry (https://mentalsymmetry.com/), but the Big Five is new to me. I imagine there’s a lot to explore, but I’ll start by dipping a cautious toe into exploring the Enneagram.

I’d love to hear from you:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

I’m April Yamasaki

Welcome to When You Work for the Church. I’ve been a church volunteer and a full-time pastor. I’ve led small groups and served on denominational committees. When I resigned from pastoral ministry to focus on my writing, I knew that I wanted to be—needed to be—grounded in a local congregation. I love the church!

But I also know that churches and church organizations have not always lived up to their calling, have brought harm instead of healing. So I started this website to share resources for doing ministry better, and pray that together we might serve more faithfully and effectively.

For a healthy rhythm of work and rest, I’d love to send you my ebook.

Let’s Connect: